Carnival of Aces: Tales (and How Not to Tell Them)

This post is for the October 2016 Carnival of Aces on Joining the Asexual Community.

[CN: brief mention of arousal and sexual attraction (non-descriptively); brief mention of abuse]

I don’t know if it’s a thing with other queer identities, but with asexuality, ‘how did you realise you were asexual’ is a question that seems to come up a lot. I wrote about it on Tumblr at some point long ago, it’s always the first question asked at irl ace meet-ups, and sometimes just folks I know at uni will ask about it. Unfortunately I still don’t have a response to that question that satisfies me; nowadays, I either lie* (not my favourite thing to do) or just dance around the question (also not my favourite thing to do).

However, today, for one night only, I’m going to try and write out my story of joining the asexual community (and why I usually don’t).

The first time I saw anything about asexuality it was (surprise, surprise) on Tumblr. It was just one of those ubiquitous pride posts and I don’t think I really thought anything of it — it was just another word to add to my vocabulary.

A little later, however, I started wondering. I’d somehow got into a conversation with this guy about celebrity crushes and it had slowly started occurring to me that he had a slightly different way of looking at attractiveness that just didn’t click with me. I still thought I found people sexually attractive, but I thought that maybe I only became attracted to people (or in the case of the conversation, celebrities [who apparently don’t count as people to my brain?]) after I got to know them a little bit better. I found myself on a wiki page for demisexuality, and I thought that maybe it fit me, but it still didn’t feel quite right. Still, I decided to just leave it alone for a while (because of course figuring I was straight was much easier anyways).

A few months later, I realised I was having some weird feelings around a friend which I’d never had before. I thought it might be sexual attraction — which meant that I’d never felt sexual attraction before. So I must be on the asexual spectrum!

I don’t count this as the point that I ‘realised’ that I was asexual, though, because that feeling (which I still don’t know how to word but now prefer to call ‘arousal’ rather than ‘attraction’) really freaked me out. It was weird, and scary, and towards someone of the same assigned gender as me. I couldn’t think of it at all, so I barely dared think about asexuality.

The point at which I really ‘realised’ was the point at which I talked to my friend about sexuality and realised that we were both in similar boats. I helped them to think about their sexuality and in turn they gave me the courage to look around AVEN. After about five minutes of looking, I signed up and started identifying as grey-asexual.

(Of course I then decided that the ‘grey’ part wasn’t as important to me so started IDing as plain asexual, and then decided that what I’d felt wasn’t attraction anyway, and then decided that my sexuality was really complicated but asexuality was useful to describe certain parts of it so it’s still a useful label to have even if it may not be relevant to my current situation of in-a-sexual-relationship, but this post is getting long enough already.)

So, that’s my tale of when I was a baby ace. Perhaps it’s partially clear from that why I don’t like telling the story, but I’ll spell it out just in case.

The basic point is that that story is so ridiculously convoluted. I feel like people who ask me that question (especially folks who aren’t ace themselves) want an answer that would fit on a postcard: ‘I always knew I was different’; ‘I just heard about asexuality and realised I didn’t feel sexual attraction’; I’m demi and I realised once I did feel sexual attraction’; and so on. No one expects a five-hundred-odd-words tale about thinking you might be, then ignoring it, then feeling sexual attraction but maybe not and ignoring it and then finally jumping in with both feet. If I could tell it in a funny way, then it perhaps might be accepted as a reasonable-length tale, but it’s such a personal and un-funny thing that it often feels egotistical or dry or irrelevant to others if you go on about it for too long.

Another reason that I hesitate to tell the tale is that it mentions sexual attraction/arousal. When I described it as sexual attraction, I didn’t have as much of a problem with telling it, but now that I personally describe it as arousal (even if I don’t say it that way in the tale), I feel like it’s too personal to mention. I don’t know if that makes me prudish or just normal, but I always feel really awkward and embarrassed telling people.

The third and final reason is that it simply isn’t a good memory for me. I think we rarely talk about these kinds of realising-I’m-ace narratives being possibly negative experiences (which is probably why I don’t just answer with ‘I don’t really want to say’). It’s weird because I think most, aces who re-tell these tales tend to have had some sort of angst around realising that they’re ace, so you’d expect us to understand that maybe not all these stories are all rainbows and ponies, but apparently not? Perhaps it’s just the circles I run in, but the only negative stories of ace realisations tend to be from people asking advice blogs what to do or asking for positivity. Those folks that ask those questions rarely seem to talk about their narratives in a format that might be shared (unsurprisingly; you don’t participate in a community that you don’t really want to be in, I guess), and those of us that do (I feel) have a tendency to look back at our baby-ace days with very rose-tinted glasses.

The fact is, not everything about my narrative is happy; I spent a lot of time thinking that no one would love me for who I was (this was pre-arospec realisation [and also, of course, pre-boyfriend]), even as I got involved with the community (and mainly the puns) on Tumblr and AVEN. The even more negative aspect, however, is that my story is so entwined with that one friend, who I ended up in a sort-of relationship with that was abusive, that now any possible happy memories I could have of finding out I was ace (and finding a world of new puns) is shadowed by that relationship. The greatest irony and pain of it is that, when I first wrote my baby-ace story on Tumblr (when I was still a baby-ace) I talked about how I was glad that I’d realised when I did, or not knowing could have caused me to do things I didn’t want to do if I was in a relationship (well done past-Mara). It’s so difficult to fit those kinds of feelings into a narrative that, again, people are hoping will fit onto a postcard, that I just don’t bother trying.

So that’s why I don’t tell this story that I have still somehow ended up telling.

*I realised part way through writing this that I never said what lie I tell and I couldn’t manage to reword things to fit it in there, so here it is: ‘I just kinda woke up one day and realised that I didn’t feel the same way that other people feel when they talk about sexual attraction’. It’s the most boring and slightly odd answer ever and even from other aces I tend to get a slightly ‘what? you just woke up one day and realised? weird.’ face.



5 thoughts on “Carnival of Aces: Tales (and How Not to Tell Them)

  1. Thank you for sharing this. I’m sorry it’s such a negative set of memories for you and that sometimes you even feel compelled to lie about the answer. In my own personal experience, when people, often ace, sometimes not ace, ask “how did you realize you were asexual?” they don’t “want an answer that would fit on a postcard” and they are used to complicated, negative, and long stories about the journey. They are just curious, and often in an ace-is-the-one-asking context, trying still to understand what are all the different ways people come to the conclusion.

    Quite honestly, I feel guilty now – although I’m not sure if I’ve ever insensitively asked someone the question either in person or via tumblr/online where it was a one-on-one thing and they would’ve felt compelled to answer, but I might’ve. It’s hard for me, person who is an open book, to always remember that some people are really private and don’t want to share about all the details of these kinds of stories. I’ll try to keep in mind, going forward, that people’s stories might be like yours though, and that they might not be comfortable sharing even the “how they figured out they were ace” side of it.

    The other side of this is really just… grey-asexuals or asexuals who have experiences that might be interpreted as and/or were sexual really commonly feel “not ace enough” to “count”. It’s really unfortunately that so many aces continue to essentially doubt their own orientation and/or fear how other aces (or how non-aces) will react if they learned the whole truth. I really really wish this wasn’t such a huge thing.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks 🙂 I think you’re probably right, and people are honestly curious but (especially with ace meet-ups, since it’s quite an obvious question to ask I guess?) it can sometimes feel similar to when people say ‘how are you’ and aren’t expecting a proper answer. Plus I have a tendency to think that talking about myself is just rambling on, so that probably exacerbates the feeling!

      There’s no reason to feel guilty! I think a lot of things that may seem innocuous to most people could be upsetting to others, especially in the context of personal things like sexuality, so while it’s good to keep in mind it would also be really hard to have any substantial conversations without asking these kinds of questions! There’s not really a good way to talk about things like this while still allowing space for people who aren’t comfortable with sharing about it, I don’t think. Checking people’s body language and caveats that people don’t have to answer if they don’t want to are kind of the best compromises I’ve found (and still, if I was answering I would probably give a proper answer anyway because I’m too passive/socially anxious to point myself out in a group like that).

      Yeah it’s such a shame that there’s that pressure there. I always feel like I should write about my experiences with sex and sexuality to try and combat the whole unassailable asexual thing, especially because my aceness kind of feels even clearer when seen through the lens of sexual stuff (if that makes even the slightest bit of sense) and also because I think I’ve got a pretty thick skin nowadays when it come to being invalidated for my asexuality, but I haven’t yet found a way to word it that I’m comfortable with.


  2. I think you bring up a good point that often the “how I realized I was asexual” stories have an underlying sadness to them. I personally felt despair when I realized I was asexual. It wasn’t a story of “I discovered what gender I love” story, but a “I’m terrified I’ll never have love” story.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: A Carnival of Aces: October 2016 Round-up of Submissions: Joining the Asexual Community | Yapbnweca

  4. I rarely tell my “realization” story anymore–I simply have too much emotional distance. However, when I used to tell it, one of things I would often repeat: “For some people, discovering asexuality was a relief. But when I found out, I was depressed for months afterwards.”

    My story was also convoluted, and really the full story would require sexually explicit details that I have no interest in sharing. But it has become simplified over time, as the details no longer matter, mostly just the outcome.

    Liked by 1 person

Have a comment to add?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s